Post by thesolution on Aug 11, 2018 13:21:18 GMT -5
Graeter's Banana Cream Pie
Graeter's Banana Cream Pie is labeled as "banana based ice cream with a hint of toffee and pieces of vanilla wafer cookies." As the bonus flavors roll out it is sad to say this is the last one of the summer. Graeter's is on a streak of using an unrefined mix in with vanilla wafer cookies. While this is a unique spin off banana cream pie, how well did the company execute on replicating this flavor!?
The banana base Graeter's uses is one of their best. Being a consumer who is not fond of fruity flavors this one raised my eyebrow. The company uses 20 pounds of banana's when making the ice cream. When I took my first bite I was in awe how pure and rich the banana shines. Hands down this is the best banana base on the market. Combine the density of Graeter's premium ice cream to a ripe and bold banana flavor and you strike gold. I thought Wegmans and Steve's made great banana ice creams, but this one goes right to the top.
Vanilla Wafer cookies are a childhood favorite of mine, and to see this on the description as a mix-in was pure nostalgia. Just like Maple Cinnamon Crunch the mix-in provides a crunchy and flaky texture. The cookies practically melt in your mouth, with a rich butter and intensely fragrant vanilla flavor. The toffee is very subtle, but comes through in the aftertaste to provide a unique twist on a classic banana cream pie. Just like Graeter's toffee bases it is a mild addition that needs to be amplified due to the overpowering base.
There is both good and bad news while wrapping up this review. The good news is this flavor is awesome, and you should grab a scoop before it is gone for good on August 19th. The bad news is the bonus flavors have come to an end. With that said 2018 was much better then 2017. Graeter's threw a lot of unrefined mix-ins, and they struck gold. I hope to see some of the 2018 bonus flavors become permanent additions to their line-up (Banana Cream Pie & Maple Cinnamon Crunch) for online ordering and grocery stores.
Grade: B+
Found: Graeters Scoop Shop
Wexford, PA
Ranking of Bonus Flavors for 2018:
1 - Maple Cinnamon Crunch (Grade: A)
2 - Banana Cream Pie (Grade: B+)
3 - Caramelized Chocolate Truffle (Grade: B+)
4 - Rocky Road (Grade: B+)
5 - Cheesecake Cookies & Cream (Grade: B)
6 - Peppermint Stick Chocolate Chip (Grade: B)
7 - Pistachio (Grade: B-)
Graeter's Banana Cream Pie is labeled as "banana based ice cream with a hint of toffee and pieces of vanilla wafer cookies." As the bonus flavors roll out it is sad to say this is the last one of the summer. Graeter's is on a streak of using an unrefined mix in with vanilla wafer cookies. While this is a unique spin off banana cream pie, how well did the company execute on replicating this flavor!?
The banana base Graeter's uses is one of their best. Being a consumer who is not fond of fruity flavors this one raised my eyebrow. The company uses 20 pounds of banana's when making the ice cream. When I took my first bite I was in awe how pure and rich the banana shines. Hands down this is the best banana base on the market. Combine the density of Graeter's premium ice cream to a ripe and bold banana flavor and you strike gold. I thought Wegmans and Steve's made great banana ice creams, but this one goes right to the top.
Vanilla Wafer cookies are a childhood favorite of mine, and to see this on the description as a mix-in was pure nostalgia. Just like Maple Cinnamon Crunch the mix-in provides a crunchy and flaky texture. The cookies practically melt in your mouth, with a rich butter and intensely fragrant vanilla flavor. The toffee is very subtle, but comes through in the aftertaste to provide a unique twist on a classic banana cream pie. Just like Graeter's toffee bases it is a mild addition that needs to be amplified due to the overpowering base.
There is both good and bad news while wrapping up this review. The good news is this flavor is awesome, and you should grab a scoop before it is gone for good on August 19th. The bad news is the bonus flavors have come to an end. With that said 2018 was much better then 2017. Graeter's threw a lot of unrefined mix-ins, and they struck gold. I hope to see some of the 2018 bonus flavors become permanent additions to their line-up (Banana Cream Pie & Maple Cinnamon Crunch) for online ordering and grocery stores.
Grade: B+
Found: Graeters Scoop Shop
Wexford, PA
Ranking of Bonus Flavors for 2018:
1 - Maple Cinnamon Crunch (Grade: A)
2 - Banana Cream Pie (Grade: B+)
3 - Caramelized Chocolate Truffle (Grade: B+)
4 - Rocky Road (Grade: B+)
5 - Cheesecake Cookies & Cream (Grade: B)
6 - Peppermint Stick Chocolate Chip (Grade: B)
7 - Pistachio (Grade: B-)
